Difference between revisions of "Talk:Viewing a wiki"

Jump to: navigation, search

Note: You are currently viewing documentation for Moodle 1.9. Up-to-date documentation for the latest stable version is available here: Viewing a wiki.

(Chris suggestions)
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
== Clarity?  Shome mishtake shirly? ==
 +
 +
Sorry, it MUST be just me but in my setup (which I think is basic) these instructions don't correlate to what is on the screen in front of me.  Could the choice of theme affect things so radically?  For instance: the instructions on adding a page "Using search" simnply don't work.  No option is given to create a page if it is not found by the search engine.
 +
 +
Secondly, the information regarding Adding a Wiki Page --- From a Wiki Page, is bewildering to me.  If I figure out how it's done I'll come back and edit it  I thought after hours of searching I'd finally found THE core information on Wikis but it's short and confusing.  Even the reference to how to make a link ismn't clear.  The reference isn't a straightforward hyperlink in the form, http://etc but something else e.g. image:etc. All I get is that the link, however that is to be formatted, must be presented in square brackets.  At the moment I can't make any link at all between what's being said here and the reality of doign more than clicking add wiki in the activities box! I'm in 1.8.
 +
 +
Lastly, I'm with Chris on the naming.  As you say Helen the title of this page comes from the view, edit, links and history tabs at the top of the body of the Wiki page.  But surely this is a cryptic link?  A title normally sums up subject matter rather than referring one element of one section of the categorisation of the subject matter. If it were considered that choosing one of the tab headings was neat for some reason then it is more likely that a user would want information on doing something i.e. editing, rather than on looking at something.  To look at a wiki requires little expertise.  The confusion comes because the page Editing a wiki refers to editing the SETTINGS of a wiki and not the wiki itself.  The editing of a book is generally considered to refer to the words on the pages and not the arrangement of the binding, ink, printing press and employment contracts.  Sorry if I sound frazzled.  I am.  but I've been hunting for this information all day and it's clear than there are thousands of people here who take this information as self-evidemnt for some reason and don't seem able to share that knowledge wuth the rest of us.  If I can figure it out on my own I'll come back here and sort it.  But any help would be appreciated.
 +
 +
[[User:Robin Greaves|Robin Greaves]] 15:12, 12 October 2007 (CDT)
 +
 
== Could we rename?? ==
 
== Could we rename?? ==
  
Line 19: Line 29:
  
 
::Hi Chris, thanks for your comments :-) [[Adding/editing a wiki]] is for documentation on how to add/edit a wiki activity and is redirected from [[mod/wiki/mod]]. [[Viewing a wiki]] is for documentation on how to use the wiki activity i.e. View, Edit, Links, History and is redirected from [[mod/wiki/view]] (hence the title containing "View"). Re. wiki tips and tricks, would they be appropriate for the [[Wiki module]] page? --[[User:Helen Foster|Helen Foster]] 03:38, 7 November 2006 (CST)
 
::Hi Chris, thanks for your comments :-) [[Adding/editing a wiki]] is for documentation on how to add/edit a wiki activity and is redirected from [[mod/wiki/mod]]. [[Viewing a wiki]] is for documentation on how to use the wiki activity i.e. View, Edit, Links, History and is redirected from [[mod/wiki/view]] (hence the title containing "View"). Re. wiki tips and tricks, would they be appropriate for the [[Wiki module]] page? --[[User:Helen Foster|Helen Foster]] 03:38, 7 November 2006 (CST)
 
== Clarity?  Shome mishtake shirly? ==
 
 
Sorry, it MUST be just me but in my setup (which I think is basic) these instructions don't correlate to what is on the screen in front of me.  Could the choice of theme affect things so radically?  For instance: the instructions on adding a page "Using search" simnply don't work.  No option is given to create a page if it is not found by the search engine.
 
 
Secondly, the information regarding Adding a Wiki Page --- From a Wiki Page, is bewildering to me.  If I figure out how it's done I'll come back and edit it  I thought after hours of searching I'd finally found THE core information on Wikis but it's short and confusing.  Even the reference to how to make a link ismn't clear.  The reference isn't a straightforward hyperlink in the form, http://etc but something else e.g. image:etc. All I get is that the link, however that is to be formatted, must be presented in square brackets.  At the moment I can't make any link at all between what's being said here and the reality of doign more than clicking add wiki in the activities box! I'm in 1.8.
 
 
Lastly, I'm with Chris on the naming.  As you say Helen the title of this page comes from the view, edit, links and history tabs at the top of the body of the Wiki page.  But surely this is a cryptic link?  A title normally sums up subject matter rather than referring one element of one section of the categorisation of the subject matter. If it were considered that choosing one of the tab headings was neat for some reason then it is more likely that a user would want information on doing something i.e. editing, rather than on looking at something.  To look at a wiki requires little expertise.  The confusion comes because the page Editing a wiki refers to editing the SETTINGS of a wiki and not the wiki itself.  The editing of a book is generally considered to refer to the words on the pages and not the arrangement of the binding, ink, printing press and employment contracts.  Sorry if I sound frazzled.  I am.  but I've been hunting for this information all day and it's clear than there are thousands of people here who take this information as self-evidemnt for some reason and don't seem able to share that knowledge wuth the rest of us.  If I can figure it out on my own I'll come back here and sort it.  But any help would be appreciated.
 
 
[[User:Robin Greaves|Robin Greaves]] 15:12, 12 October 2007 (CDT)
 

Revision as of 20:13, 12 October 2007

Clarity? Shome mishtake shirly?

Sorry, it MUST be just me but in my setup (which I think is basic) these instructions don't correlate to what is on the screen in front of me. Could the choice of theme affect things so radically? For instance: the instructions on adding a page "Using search" simnply don't work. No option is given to create a page if it is not found by the search engine.

Secondly, the information regarding Adding a Wiki Page --- From a Wiki Page, is bewildering to me. If I figure out how it's done I'll come back and edit it I thought after hours of searching I'd finally found THE core information on Wikis but it's short and confusing. Even the reference to how to make a link ismn't clear. The reference isn't a straightforward hyperlink in the form, http://etc but something else e.g. image:etc. All I get is that the link, however that is to be formatted, must be presented in square brackets. At the moment I can't make any link at all between what's being said here and the reality of doign more than clicking add wiki in the activities box! I'm in 1.8.

Lastly, I'm with Chris on the naming. As you say Helen the title of this page comes from the view, edit, links and history tabs at the top of the body of the Wiki page. But surely this is a cryptic link? A title normally sums up subject matter rather than referring one element of one section of the categorisation of the subject matter. If it were considered that choosing one of the tab headings was neat for some reason then it is more likely that a user would want information on doing something i.e. editing, rather than on looking at something. To look at a wiki requires little expertise. The confusion comes because the page Editing a wiki refers to editing the SETTINGS of a wiki and not the wiki itself. The editing of a book is generally considered to refer to the words on the pages and not the arrangement of the binding, ink, printing press and employment contracts. Sorry if I sound frazzled. I am. but I've been hunting for this information all day and it's clear than there are thousands of people here who take this information as self-evidemnt for some reason and don't seem able to share that knowledge wuth the rest of us. If I can figure it out on my own I'll come back here and sort it. But any help would be appreciated.

Robin Greaves 15:12, 12 October 2007 (CDT)

Could we rename??

It seems to me rather counter-intuitive for this page to be called "viewing a wiki" when its subject matter is virtually exclusively "Editing a wiki". This page is the ESSENTIAL information needed for a user on adding and editing pages. This information is NOWHERE else (as far as I can see), and it is hard to find because of the (previous) abscenvce of links to it from the pages that are relatively easy to find. So there :) Can "we" rename it??? Also, why is it necessary to have the three or four pages: WikiModule, Addin/Editing, and Viewing. Adding/Editing is also a little misleading as it refers to the editing involved in SETTING UP a wili rather than adding/editing content of the wiki (what users would think of AS the wiki) after it has been set up. Couldn't the three pages be brought together? I'd do it but I guess that would be rather presumptuous!! Robin Greaves 14:27, 12 October 2007 (CDT)

Wiki tags

Just a caution. MoodleDocs is a MediaWiki. The standard wiki that comes with Moodle is very different. The Help:editing link is for MoodleDocs and could frustrate new users because some of those features will not work in the Standard Moodle wiki. The "new" wiki that will become part of Moodle sometime in the near future should be different than the current "old" version. Thanks for the edits --chris collman 11:46, 2 March 2007 (CST)

Chris suggestions

Humm, nice content but I am confused about how CameLCase notation relates to viewing. We have the Adding a wiki page, which also contains info on editing. I am not sure what "Viewing a wiki" means. Viewing to me is passive, read only.

The real good unique stuff here are tips about structuring a wiki. I am sure there are more examples out there.

  1. Suggest renaming this page "Wiki tips and tricks" then we can edit accordingly
  2. Maybe we need to change the adding page to the standard "Adding/editing a wiki page" page.
  3. Need to point the reader to either a specific Moodle wiki module format page or the general link I have seen but not visited
  4. I am staying clear of the standard, non-standard versions of a wiki module :) --chris collman 12:23, 6 November 2006 (CST)
Hi Chris, thanks for your comments :-) Adding/editing a wiki is for documentation on how to add/edit a wiki activity and is redirected from mod/wiki/mod. Viewing a wiki is for documentation on how to use the wiki activity i.e. View, Edit, Links, History and is redirected from mod/wiki/view (hence the title containing "View"). Re. wiki tips and tricks, would they be appropriate for the Wiki module page? --Helen Foster 03:38, 7 November 2006 (CST)